On May 9, 2025, two neighboring houses on Byram Shore Road changed hands on the same day, one for $10,130,000 and the other for $3,150,000. The next day, a house on Byram Road, a short drive inland, sold for $795,000. All three are Byram addresses, and all three end up in the same neighborhood statistics. A buyer who reads Byram from those statistics is averaging two markets that share a name and little else.
The averages for Byram shift with whether one waterfront house happened to close during the period. The inland market holds steady from one period to the next and moves fast. Pricing a Byram purchase starts with separating the two.
Ten Sales in Both Years, With Very Different Totals
Greenwich market columns often use school districts as stand-ins for neighborhoods. In a Greenwich Sentinel neighborhood report published October 11, 2026, the New Lebanon district is described as close to the boundaries of Byram and Pemberwick. That district had 10 single-family sales in the first nine months of 2026, the same number as in the first nine months of 2025. Those ten 2026 sales totaled $12.4 million, down $21.5 million from the same period of 2025. The report attributes the drop to one of the district's highly valuable Byram Shore Road houses selling in 2025 and none selling in 2026.
The arithmetic is simple. Ten sales totaling about $33.9 million in the first nine months of 2025 average roughly $3.39 million per house. Ten sales totaling $12.4 million in the same months of 2026 average about $1.24 million. The number of sales did not change, and the Sentinel ties the difference to the shore. The town's 2025 transfer records list several Byram Shore Road closings between April and July of that year, recorded at $3.15 million to $10.13 million.
The same pattern shows up at every interval. For the first half of 2026, the Sentinel's July 21 report counted 7 New Lebanon sales totaling $7.96 million, down $16.8 million from the first half of 2025. The column told readers to take the district's numbers "with a grain of salt." That leaves three sales totaling about $4.44 million in the third quarter of 2026, or roughly $1.48 million each. That is close to where the inland transfers below land.
Price per square foot is usually the steadier measure, and in Byram it moves too. Through the first nine months of 2026, New Lebanon had Greenwich's lowest average sold price per square foot, $651. It was also the only district where that average fell. Earlier in the year, the Sentinel's April 20, 2026 column measured Byram itself rather than the school district. For the first quarter of 2026, Byram's average sale price was down 56% year over year while its average sold price per square foot was up 83%. The column called both changes anomalous and said they came from "the law of small numbers." It added that Byram's other measures, including sale price to assessment, days on market and sale price to original list price, all pointed to a hot market. In the same column, Byram was one of the neighborhoods where buyers had to be prepared to move quickly.
So a district can have the lowest price per square foot in town and still be competitive. The lowest-in-town figure comes from which houses sold, not from buyers losing interest.
The Inland Streets, Address by Address
The steadier market is visible in the town's property transfers, which the Greenwich Free Press publishes as they are recorded. These are recent transfers on clearly Byram and Pemberwick streets:
| Street | Recorded | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Byram Road | May 10, 2025 | $795,000 |
| Byram Road | July 25, 2025 | $1,000,000 |
| North Water Street, a multifamily house | October 1, 2025 | $1,700,000 |
| Byram Terrace Drive | July 15, 2026 | $1,675,000 |
| North Water Street | September 1, 2026 | $970,000 |
| Pemberwick Road | September 2, 2026 | $1,150,000 |
The transfer lists do not record property type, so the table mixes houses of different kinds and sizes. The range is still narrow. In the 2026 rows, prices run from $970,000 to $1,675,000. The Greenwich Association of REALTORS® third-quarter release put the townwide single-family median at $3,368,790 for the third quarter of 2026. The 2026 inland transfers fall between about 29% and 50% of that figure.
This is the part of Byram that the averages hide when a shore house closes. The housing is a mix of modest colonials, wood-frame houses with porches, and apartments, with the Byram River docks, Rosenwald Park and Byram Pool nearby and the Capitol Theatre just over the line in Port Chester.
The Shore Trades on Its Own Calendar
South Byram Shore Road belongs to a different set of comparables. In a June 22, 2026 Sentinel column on sales above $10 million, it is the westernmost of Greenwich's private waterfront associations, listed alongside Belle Haven, Indian Harbor and Mead Point as a place where the town's high-end sales concentrate. The recent trades look like that company. Besides the two May 2025 sales above, a Byram Shore Road property transferred together with a Byram Dock Street parcel for $6,423,500 on April 30, 2025.
These sales come rarely and in large amounts. A buyer shopping the shore should compare it with Belle Haven or Mead Point, not with Byram Road. A buyer shopping inland should drop the shore sales from the comparables entirely. In a district where ten sales produced $12.4 million through September 2026, a single $10 million closing nearly equals that whole total, and it says nothing about what a house on Byram Terrace Drive is worth.
What the Mill Street Corner Adds
The inland market has also drawn commercial investment. On October 1, 2025, Greenport Corners LLC, registered to Toros H. Mangassarian of Rye, New York, bought four properties at the intersection of Mill Street and North Water Street for a total of $9 million. The parcels included 2-6 North Water Street, the former Laundry Room site, for $2.5 million. They also included 13 North Water Street, long the home of Greenview Pharmacy, for $2.4 million, and 14 North Water Street, a multifamily house dating to 1894 on about 0.115 acres, for $1.7 million.
According to the Greenwich Free Press, the plan by developer Chris Franco of The Franco Group calls for restoring 13 and 14 North Water Street and renovating the former Famous Greek Kitchen building at 10 North Water Street with retail below and apartments above. It also calls for a new three-story brick building on the corner, with a commercial ground floor that Franco said would suit a restaurant. In June, Franco told the paper that the evening-wear shop Flora on Madison planned to take the retail space at 13 North Water Street, and that the three-family house at 14 would stay a three-family house. "This is very exciting and it's meaningful to do something for this side of town," he told the Greenwich Free Press.
For a residential buyer, the $1.7 million paid for 14 North Water Street is one more data point that sits with the inland transfers, not with the shore. It also shows investors paying inland Byram prices for small, century-old buildings within walking distance of Mill Street.
Pricing an Inland Byram Offer
Start with Byram and Pemberwick sales that are clearly inland and recent, and leave out any Byram Shore Road closing in the same window. Use price per square foot only after taking out the shore sales, because the district's $651 average comes from whichever houses happened to sell. Expect the pace of a hot submarket. Townwide, the Sentinel's October report put median days on market at 17 for the first nine months of 2026, against an average of 90 that a few long-listed houses pull up. The Greenwich Association of REALTORS® reported an average of 38 days on market for the third quarter of 2026, down from 56 a year earlier. Our Byram neighborhood page and market reports are the place to start, and our earlier piece on Greenwich micro-markets applies the same reasoning across the rest of town.
A Few Questions Buyers Ask About Byram
Is Byram part of Greenwich? Yes. Byram is one of Greenwich's communities, with Port Chester, New York, just over the line.
Why did Byram's average price fall while its price per square foot rose? In the first quarter of 2026, the Sentinel column attributed both changes to a small number of sales with a very wide spread of prices. Other measures, including days on market and sale price to original list price, pointed to a hot market.
Which sales should an inland Byram buyer compare against? Recent inland transfers, which closed between $970,000 and $1,675,000 in 2026. South Byram Shore Road trades with Greenwich's other private waterfront associations, and its 2025 sales ran from about $3 million to $10 million.
Byram rewards a buyer who prices it street by street rather than from the district average. If you are weighing an inland Byram house or a place on the shore, Charles Paternina & Associates will put together comparables for that address, with the waterfront sales separated out, before you write an offer. Request a Private Consultation.